I Refuse to Pay for My Niece’s College, Even Though I Got Her Late Dad’s Inheritance

month ago

Read 26 comments

I Refuse to Pay for My Niece’s College, Even Though I Got Her Late Dad’s Inheritance

I never imagined I would be in this twisted situation where my own family treats me like the villain. I thought I had a decent relationship with my niece, and I always tried to be supportive in ways that felt reasonable. But recently, things took a turn that I did not see coming. Not only is my niece ungrateful for things I’ve done for her, but she’s making me regret them.

Hi Bright Side readers!

Please, read my story before you judge. When my niece was only three years old, my brother died in a horrible accident. Our whole family fell apart for a while. He was a young single dad, and no one expected something like that to happen.

It turned out that in his will, he left all his money to me. He trusted me, obviously, and he made that choice on his own.

AI-generated image

I have rethought my previous comment. Let me take a wild guess. You were the executor for your brother’s estate, weren’t you? You are in serious trouble. You signed documents that spelled out your responsibilities, one of which was to settle all of your brother’s debts and other obligations before any payment was to be made to named beneficiaries. Well, providing child support for that minor child was one of those obligations. He could not exclude her from inheritance even if he wanted to. Whether you knew that or not, you failed to exercise your responsibility as executor. You (or whoever was executor) are certainly civilly and likely criminally liable. If you want to avoid criminal penalties you had better be the first one to make a move to straighten this out.

-

-

Reply

I showered his daughter with love, but I was not her parent. She was adopted. I put her over myself and my life multiple times and helped where I could, showed up for important moments, bought her things here and there, gave her birthday presents, and tried to be someone she could always rely on emotionally.

For years, there was never any mention of the inheritance. Not once. In fact, as she grew up, she became more distant.

Fast-forward to recently. She is nineteen now and getting ready for college. Out of nowhere, she called me. No warning, no warm up, no conversation.

She went straight into it. Her exact words were, “Send me dad’s money. I need it for college.” It felt like she was demanding something that I stole from her.

© diana.grytsku / Freepik

I told her the truth. The money was mine. Her father left it to me, not to her. He never said it was meant to be a college fund or a savings plan for my niece. He left it directly to me. I was firm but not rude.

I said I could not give her the inheritance as I need the funds for my own son’s education and I feel as if I’ve given more than enough to her already. She immediately hung up. No goodbye, no discussion, nothing.

Two days later, things got worse. I found out she had told several extended family members and close friends that I was stealing her father’s money “wrongfully” and refusing to pay for her future. She made it sound like I was hoarding something that legally belonged to her and that I had been secretly sitting on it while she struggled.

People started messaging me, calling me selfish and heartless. Some even hinted that I should be ashamed for using “her dad’s money” on myself or just be “understanding, kind” and do what my brother “would’ve wanted”. MY brother left his money to ME.

© freepik / Freepik

It would be a good idea for you to speak with an attorney. Not sure how your brother's will was worded. You say your niece was adopted; not sure what happened with her bio mother. If your brother flat out left the money to you without stipulations on how it was to be used, then it's yours and what you do with it is your business based on your values and needs.

-

-

Reply

I also never signed up to be her financial backup plan. I never agreed to pay her tuition. What hurt most was her reaction.

If she had come to me politely, talked to me like a human, asked for help or advice, I might have tried to support her in smaller ways. But demanding money and acting like it was owed to her made things feel completely different. It turned everything into a transaction.

My niece still refuses to talk to me directly. She only communicates through vague posts and messages sent through other people. I keep thinking about that moment she hung up on me. It stings more than the money ever could, and I think our relationship is beyond repair at this point.

Sometimes doing the right thing for yourself makes you look like the bad guy. I can live with that. But I do wonder. Am I really in the wrong here, or are people just picking sides without thinking logically?

In our previous letter, a man shared how he suffered terrible consequences after he refused to do a pregnant coworker’s work for free. Read the full story: I Refuse to Cover My Pregnant Coworker for Free, Now HR Is Involved

Comments

Get notifications

Don't let others gaslight you, the money is righfully and legally yours. If your niece is so rude, she can get help from her real parents.

3

4

Reply

Lol no coming from someone who works in finance, they are absolutely screwed. They are incredibly lucky in one aspect that it took this long to catch up to them, but it screws them more in the long term

-

-

Reply

It is pretty clear that your brother left the money to YOU, with NO EXPECTATIONS of you, saving anything for his daughter. HE CHOSE where he wanted it to go. Whatever his reasoning for doing that was, NO ONE, NOT EVEN THE CHILDREN are entitled to money, or houses, or jewelry, or ANYTHING ELSE, left by the deceased. I can't make this decision for you, but I believe that your brother had his reasons for leaving it to you. DON'T LET ANYONE GUILT YOU, or BULLY YOU. You don't owe her anything.

4

3

Reply

But like, who wouldn't leave their money to their 3 yro child? It makes 0 sense for this to be real

2

-

Reply

He may well have been one of the people who think that because they are ADOPTING, it makes them a special person. However, they have NO intention of including the adopted child in the "FAMILY" inheritance. I have read about it quite often on this forum. Ultimately AND unfortunately, family or not, blood or not, NO ONE is entitled to another person's estate, unless specifically stated.

-

1

Reply

Maybe? It would seem weird for it to not be mentioned though
However, you could be wrong on that last bit depending where OP lives. Some countries/states have a protection against essientially disinheriting children, espeically minors i do believe, where if they arent left anything they can sue to get something and the courts will circumvent the will. This seems like a case that would be likely, IF that is where OP lives

I just find it really strange and kinda fake, that a single dad would have done this. Worlds strange sometimes though

1

-

Reply

I didn't think about that, and it is quite sad, if he did indeed not include her because she was adopted. But considering he died when she was 3, and is 19 now, it's probably WAY past the statute of limitations. The "World is STRANGE" is an understatement.

-

1

Reply

Some places would allow it as she was a minor until recently, so it is up in the air

For a minor, the statute of limitations to sue about a will generally starts running after they turn 19 (the age of majority) and may be influenced by when they discovered the claim.

2

-

Reply

Wow, you just explained some things that I didn't know. Thank you. That will have an impact on my future comments.

-

1

Reply

You mean when he unexpectedly died in a horrific accident when the child was still a baby? Those are OPs own words by the way. Yea...sorry to tell you but it's clear you know nothing about about how finance works. OP got lucky for years and are quite deservedly screwed. Now they will owe not only all the money back, but with a good amount of interest it should have been earning when set up for the child like it should have been.

1

1

Reply

You keep HARPING on FINANCE. IF she was his bio child, he should have put her in his will IMMEDIATELY AFTER SHE WAS BORN. IF she was his adopted child he should have put her in his will IMMEDIATELY AFTER SHE WAS ADOPTED. SEE HOW THAT WORKS. Even though he died in an unforseen accident, she was ALREADY IN HIS LIFE! You don't WAIT when your child comes into your life, you protect them FROM THE START. He never did that, he never said anything about that to OP. While it IS SAD, and OP SHOULD have been more cognizant of the child's needs, they had NO LEGAL OBLIGATION. IF YOU knew anything about FINANCE, you would know that unexpected death, poor investments, and ANYTHING ELSE that happened to the child's father, IS NOT OP's responsibility or problem. OP has NO obligation, or responsibility because their brother chose to leave them their assets and NOT THEIR OWN CHILD. It sucks but THAT IS LIFE.

-

1

Reply

It's legally yours. But I wonder if you bother was alive what he would say. It's seems weird that he would leave all the money to you without making sure his daughter was covered. Make me wonder if he made that decision before his daughter was born and forgot to change it. Her approach was wrong but if you had passed and gave the money to your brother would you want him to help your son out?

1

-

Reply

These comments are unbelievable. Your brother died in an untimely accident and it is safe to assume he forgot to update the will to include his adopted daughter. You could at least be decent and pay for the girl's college.

8

4

Reply

He didn't FORGET TO UPDATE THE WILL, IF he was going to do that, he would have done it as soon as she came into his life. It sucks, but it is NOT THE OP'S RESPONSIBILITY. Especially since she was a DEMANDING, ENTITLED BRAT. Had she showed the least bit of kindness, she may have fared better.

-

3

Reply

You don't understand finance or reading comprehension. The child was adopted AFTER her father died.

-

1

Reply

What does THAT have to do with the him NOT putting her in his will, sometime in her FIRST 3 YEARS OF LIFE? If she was his bio kid, why didn't he put her in his will, as soon as she was born? He may have been stupid for not doing it, but that is not OP'S problem. It sucks, but that's life. As far as coming for me? My major in college was BUSINESS ENGLISH, minored in ECONOMICS, SO, you lose on BOTH COUNTS. I understand more than you know, and have had more PRACTICAL LIFE EXPERIENCE, than most. Maybe you should brush up on YOUR credentials, cuz I am ALL GOOD.

-

1

Reply

Mary Rose Nelson

I don't think the deceased brother adopted the girl. I think she was adopted after her fathers death. I also think he didn't update his will and that's why the money was not left to her. Instead of little gifts here and there, the OP should have set up a fund for her with some of the money for her future.

3

-

Reply

Yta. The child already lost her dad and your flat out refusal is quite concerning. Do the right thing dude.your brother probably didn't update his will. If I was your family I would disown you too.

1

1

Reply

You have betrayed your brothers trust, plain and simple. He clearly trusted you to manage the money morally, and for one reason or another, chose not to put it in a trust, and you have behaved treasonously to award your nieces money to your son. The fact you bring up her adoption shows that you don't really consider her family ... that's probably why she grew more distant. Your brother likely was uneducated on estate matters, and likely had he lived would have redone his will to leave the money to his child ... he did the wrong thing with his money as a result, and you jumped on his error and used it to benefit yourself. You should be ashamed of your selfish treason. You are correct, of course, that she has no legal recourse, or legal right to the money. The right is a moral one, and that makes you a moral failure.

4

-

Reply

Some of the comments are grossly unrealistic and your being greedy. You know darn good and well thats hes daughter. Thats why you never mentioned the inheritance you were hoping and praying she'd remain ignorant. Well. Sweet pea that didn't happen. If you had one decent bone in your body you'd you'd give her a certain percentage. But for some reason when relatives pass away....money becomes their god. I don't know you feel like that phone conversation stung. You got out of it just what you put into it. Good ol fashion GREED

3

1

Reply

when did your brother make the will? if it was after his daughter came into his life, then you have the moral high ground. if it was before, you are legally in the right but morally suspect.

2

1

Reply

Maybe try sitting down with her and tell her you'll help her with some of it but she needs to provide some help herself. Since your brother didn't specify what he wanted you to do with the money it's really your decision. Tell her you'll help with some money but she needs to help also. Remind her he left it to you and you'll help but she needs to also help herself too. Hopefully yall can work this out peacefully. Best of luck to you.

-

1

Reply

Christy Cornett

You should have put it in a trust. It wasn't yours and your lucky the girl doesn't get an attorney because she is the legally entitled to it. He adopted her that makes her the legal next of kin. And why is it OK for you to use it for your son and not her just show a darker side of you... shame on you.

3

-

Reply

Unless the brother’s will was made after the birth of his daughter and specifically mentioned and excluded her, she was clearly entitled to some or even all of his estate. The statute of limitations for civil redress did not start running until she came of age. She needs a lawyer.

3

-

Reply

This money is not yours, you should return the money to its owner your niece

1

-

Reply

I have been on brightside for 6 yrs, never logged in. But when I read this one, I just had to. You are morally suspect. How can you even think of using your brother's money for your kid, but not his kid?
If you can not understand this, then you are not the person that your poor brother thought you would be.

1

-

Reply

Related Reads