12 Eerie Stories That Get More Disturbing the More You Think
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c588d/c588d07fe23f26cfa292b852c49debe9955217c9" alt="12 Eerie Stories That Get More Disturbing the More You Think"
Imagine stumbling upon a fortune hidden right inside your home. Sounds like a dream, right? For these lucky folks, it became reality! From antique artifacts to secret rooms, these discoveries turned ordinary houses into treasure troves.
In New York City, where weird housing stories aren’t unusual, this one was extra strange. Samantha, 26, shared her adventure on TikTok. Soon, millions were watching. People even compared her story to movies like Parasite and Candyman.
Her video kicks off with a cold breeze blowing through her bathroom. It even messed up her hair! When she looked behind the mirror, she was stunned. A secret apartment was right there.
Instead of running away like in every scary movie. Samantha thought, “I can’t not know what’s on the other side of my bathroom.” So she grabbed a few things, a headlamp, a mask and a hammer (her roommate even joked, “Mean it when you swing it!”)
Then she squeezed through the hole in her wall. She even warned her viewers that this kind of stunt could be dangerous. Thankfully, she made it out without a scratch.
Inside, Samantha found open windows, piles of trash bags, and even an empty water bottle, which she called a “sign of life.” Wandering through the dim, eerie rooms, Samantha had goosebumps running down her spine. “I was kind of expecting there to be somebody, especially with the water bottle being there. And that definitely put me on edge,” she opened up later.
After looking around, Samantha realized the hidden space was not meant for living. The floors were ripped up, pipes were exposed, and there was not even a toilet or tub in sight. Even the building managers are scratching their heads over this mystery.
For now, Samantha is keeping her distance from that creepy bathroom. Still, she can’t help laughing at the thought that New Yorkers, always dreaming of more space, might be jealous of her secret room. “I think everybody in New York has such small apartments, you don’t know what you’re going to find. And everyone’s hoping for more space,” she said with a laugh.
A Michigan couple bought a fixer-upper. They were ready for a big renovation. But they never expected to uncover a hidden piece of history under their feet. They were removing an old jacuzzi in their Lake Huron home (yes, that famous waterway between the US and Canada). While doing so, Hayley and her husband Trevor found a water-filled chamber 20 feet below the surface.
It turned out that behind the old spa was a manhole-like opening. This opening led to a secret room connected to the lake by a six-foot pipe. The local chatter? Possibly a Prohibition-era tunnel or a secret path for smuggling drinks.
Hayley mentioned that their house had a real 1970s vibe. They planned to remove the jacuzzi anyway. But finding this hidden chamber totally changed their plans. And get this, there’s about three feet of concrete between each floor!
At first, the discovery was a little spooky. “I think anyone finding a manhole under their house in pitch darkness is going to find it spooky,” Hayley joked. Luckily, the water was crystal clear. Nothing too wild was lurking inside. They worked up the nerve and even dove in to explore the room.
They discovered that the passageway stretched out into a huge corridor. Pumping the water out? Not an option. The water keeps flowing in from Lake Huron and nearby rivers. A never-ending flow!
Neighbors have shared all kinds of theories about the room’s past:
Back in the Prohibition days, Lake Huron and the St. Clair River were busy routes for bootleggers. In fact, one historian noted that the area was behind 75% of the illegal drinks exports.
Courtney and Matt, a millennial couple, are taking TikTok by storm after uncovering secret rooms, hidden compartments, and mysterious treasures in their 130-year-old Victorian home. And the best part? It all began with a spine-tingling letter from the “last surviving member” of the family who once lived there.
“We got a letter addressed ’purchaser,’” Courtney shared in her now-viral TikTok video. The mysterious note, sent from Canada, revealed some jaw-dropping secrets about their historic home.
“It says, ’Let me introduce myself. I am the last surviving member of the Madison family who once owned the house, and I grew up in it,’” Courtney read. “I would like to... tell you about the secret rooms and a few things you may not have been told when you bought the house.” Talk about a plot twist!
While Courtney and Matt haven’t disclosed the exact location of their home or much about the Madison family, they gave their TikTok audience a thrilling tour of their Victorian-era beauty, purchased from a historical society. And let’s just say, what they found feels like something straight out of a mystery novel.
Their first jaw-dropping discovery? A hidden cabinet cleverly concealed behind a sliding, mirrored panel above the fireplace in their parlor. Inside, they uncovered dusty bottles of vintage alcohol, including French rosé from 1970, cabernet sauvignon from 1989, and aged bourbon, beer, and cream sherry.
“Talk about a hidden happy hour!” Courtney joked.
Next, the couple followed the letter’s instructions to locate a “secret room” hidden in the bathroom. With curiosity piqued (and their toddler in tow), they ventured into what Courtney called “by far the scariest room” in the house, thanks to its shabby, antiquated vibe.
Instead of finding a proper room, they uncovered a creepy crawl space. “My guess is there probably used to be some sort of room up here,” Courtney speculated, “but really, it’s just a creepy attic space.”
But the bathroom wasn’t done revealing its secrets. Courtney and Matt also discovered a small, locked door opposite the toilet, which led to a much larger space: a trunk room.
“There is this huge space,” Courtney exclaimed. “We’re going to try and figure out how to use this space, but right now it’s just kind of a cool, cool room.”
As if the hidden rooms weren’t enough, the house also came with antique treasures left behind by the previous owners. Among the fascinating finds? A vintage music box that plays a haunting rendition of the wedding march when cranked.
“Oh, my God!” Courtney exclaimed in a TikTok clip, which has already garnered 1.2 million views. “Every day, a new treasure.”
I refused to babysit my grandkids — I’m a grandma, not a free nanny. My son and DIL love dumping their kids on me. They demanded I babysit on Christmas so they could party. Didn’t even ask if I was free, like I don’t have a life! When I refused, they acted like it was my job. So I said, “If you can’t handle being parents, maybe you shouldn’t have had kids.” They exploded... Click here to read the whole story!