My MIL Forbade Me From Coming to Thanksgiving - There Was Heinous Plot Behind It

Family & kids
5 hours ago

The holidays are often a mix of joy and stress, especially when family tensions come into play. Nancy, a newlywed, finds herself caught between honoring her boundaries and navigating a complicated relationship with her in-laws. Her story of love, loyalty, and holiday drama is one many will relate to this season. Read on as she shares her dilemma and seeks advice on how to handle it.

I think, I can never earn over which I paid by my precedent employer, but I was wrong, world is so large to try their fate. but now I am making $52/h even more,and easily earn minimum $1300/week, on the experience everyone must try to do work online, easy way to earn, here's an example.
𝐰𝐰𝐰.Richnow05

-
-
Reply

Nancy, your story is more common than you might think, but that doesn’t make it any less painful. Navigating in-law dynamics is tough, especially when they clash with your values. Your feelings of anger, betrayal, and exhaustion are valid—this isn’t just about Christmas dinner; it’s about boundaries, respect, and what kind of partnership you want in your marriage. Let’s unpack this situation and offer you the perspective and advice you need.

Let’s address the root of the tension.

Your decision to elope. Eloping is an incredibly personal choice, often made by couples to prioritize their love over others’ expectations. You didn’t “disgrace the family” as Susan claimed; you exercised your right to make a decision that felt right for you and Mark. This isn’t a betrayal—it’s autonomy. However, it’s clear that Susan saw this as a personal slight rather than a declaration of independence.

Here’s the thing, Nancy: your choice to elope wasn’t just about you and Mark—it also shined a light on his family’s deep-seated need for control. That’s a tough thing for them to grapple with, and their reaction says more about them than it does about you.

One of the most hurtful parts of your letter is Mark’s reaction —or lack thereof.

While we understand that he’s torn between his wife and his mother, it’s concerning that he hasn’t stood up for you. Marriage is about partnership, and that includes protecting each other from unfair treatment, even when it comes from family. When Susan uninvited you from Thanksgiving, Mark had a responsibility to step in and make it clear that your exclusion wasn’t acceptable.

His failure to prioritize you over his mother is a red flag, Nancy. It’s not about him choosing between the two of you—it’s about him acknowledging that you are his partner now. Marriage means that you and Mark are a team, and his reluctance to act like a teammate must be addressed.

Susan’s behavior is manipulative, plain and simple.

From calling your marriage a disgrace to trying to orchestrate a wedding you didn’t want, she’s exerting control over your life. The meltdown over the “big wedding” wasn’t just about the event—it was a statement of dominance. By demanding your presence, she’s asserting her authority in your relationship.

But Nancy, you are under no obligation to play along. You’ve already made your stance clear by eloping, and attending the Christmas dinner on these terms might reinforce her belief that she can dictate your choices. Your boundaries are not only reasonable but necessary to maintain your self-respect.

Now, let’s address the heart of your question: are you wrong for refusing to attend?

The answer is no. You have every right to protect your peace and stand by your values. However, refusing to go doesn’t mean you can’t eventually work toward healing. Forgiveness doesn’t have to mean reconciliation on someone else’s terms.

Consider this: instead of attending the dinner, offer to have an open conversation with Susan and Mark about your feelings. Let them know you’re willing to rebuild bridges, but only if there’s mutual respect and understanding. By taking the high road in this way, you’re showing that you’re open to resolution without compromising your boundaries.

Nancy, you’re not the “bad guy.”

You’re a person who deserves respect, partnership, and understanding. This isn’t just about a holiday dinner—it’s about the foundation of your marriage and the dynamics you’re willing to accept moving forward. Standing firm doesn’t make you unkind; it makes you strong.

Take the time you need to decide how to approach this situation, but remember: your happiness and self-respect are just as important as keeping the peace. In the end, a relationship built on mutual respect will stand the test of time—dinners, meltdowns, and all. We’re rooting for you.

If navigating family drama during the holidays feels overwhelming, you’re not alone. Sometimes, festive gatherings take a chaotic turn, and the stories that come from them can be surprisingly eye-opening. We’ve compiled a collection of wild holiday mishaps that will make you laugh, cringe, and maybe even feel a little better about your situation—don’t miss it!

Comments

Get notifications
Lucky you! This thread is empty,
which means you've got dibs on the first comment.
Go for it!

Related Reads