11 Movies That Based Their Plot on a True Story but Still Changed Some Important Details
When producing a film that is based on real events, the project team usually conducts a thorough fact check to make it as close to reality as possible. However, sometimes, there are some details of the protagonists that can be changed, and the viewers do not get to know them; for example, their real name or their age at the time they are to be reflected in the film.
At Bright Side, we did our own research and found 11 movies based on real events in which some modifications were made to the lives of the characters.
1. The elderly couple in Titanic
The elderly couple who appear in one of the scenes of this film, hugging in bed as water floods their room, were inspired by real Titanic passengers, Macy’s department store co-owners Rosalie Ida Straus and Isidor Straus. They died in the sinking of the liner, but not in their room. This fact was somewhat distorted, as Isidor and Ida were last seen together on the deck of the ship, holding hands, before a wave swept them out to sea.
2. The real Jack Dawson from Titanic
When the director of this film, James Cameron, was writing the script, he intended the main characters to be completely fictional, but later discovered that there was a real J. Dawson on the ship, who died on board. Joseph Dawson was an Irishman who was born in 1888. On the Titanic, he was in charge of bringing coal to the workers who were in the furnaces, as well as making sure that the piles of this material were correctly distributed to maintain the balance of the ship.
3. Queen Gorgo, from 300
In this film, Queen Gorgo told a Persian messenger: “Only Spartan women give birth to real men.” However, according to the Greek historian Plutarch in Book III of his Moralia, called “Sayings of the Spartans,” she actually gave this answer to an Athenian woman who had asked her, “Why can Spartan women speak amongst men?”
4. William Wallace, from Braveheart
This Scottish hero was supposed to be around 20 years old at the time of the film. However, Mel Gibson, who brings him to life, was almost 40 years old at the time of production.
5. Princess Isabella of France, from Braveheart
Princess Isabella of France, the wife of Edward II of England, actually arrived on this European island in 1308, so, historically, she could not have warned William Wallace about the Battle of Falkirk.
6. Mark Zuckerberg, from The Social Network
Although this film portrays the creator of Facebook as somewhat awkward with women, during much of the period covered in the film, the real Mark Zuckerberg was dating a fellow Harvard student, Priscilla Chan, who later became his wife.
7. Emily Gardner, from The Big Sick
While Kumail Nanjiani played a version of himself in the film, using his same name, he decided to change the name of his wife, Emily V. Gordon, to Emily Gardner.
8. Billy Beane, from Moneyball
Billy Beane, general manager of the Oakland Athletics, is portrayed as a lonely divorcee, even though in real life he had remarried.
9. Richard Phillips, from Capitan Phillips
In real life, the protagonist of this story never offered the pirates to be captured instead of his crew. Moreover, it is also not true that, during his captivity, he got hold of a pen and paper, or tried to write a farewell note to his family. Finally, the reaction of utter shock after being rescued, which we see played by Tom Hanks, never happened, as he was able to realize what had happened after being brought back to safety.
10. Michael Oher, from The Blind Side
The real story about the protagonist of this film, Michael Oher, is that he was already a seasoned football player when he enrolled at Briarcrest. So he was not very pleased with their depiction of him as a passive, unskilled kid who was barely familiar with football.
11. John Nash, from A Beautiful Mind
During the filming of this movie, the director decided that Nash’s hallucinations should be presented audibly and visually so that the audience could put themselves in the protagonist’s shoes. In real life, however, they were only auditory.
Do you know of any other facts that have been changed in films that are based on real events? Do you think that directors should always show the story as it was? Share your opinion with us in the comments.