So I’ve been a manager for the last seven years and I would’ve fired you so fast your head could spin. It Is completely ridiculous that she would think you are above a job that puts food on your table. If it was something that was happening over and over again I could understand but if this was a true emergency and they called you into help and you chose to ditch your job well then yep your job is gonna ditch you you need to grow up the world don’t revolve around you. They had every right to fire you. You’re not a team player you thought you were above the team, so you got cut from the team. I bet you don’t do that again. I don’t know how many people I interviewed that would come in. I don’t work the weekends? Absolutely stupid immature and ridiculous. You work whenever it’s gonna put food on your table you work one hours or given cause that’s what pays. And you were at a law firm and thought you could get away with that. How stupid you got everything you deserved.
I Refused to Go to Work on the Weekend, Even If It’s an Emergency

Balancing work responsibilities with personal time is never easy, especially when unexpected emergencies come up. Some industries demand round-the-clock dedication, while others try to respect weekends and family life, which can lead to tough choices for employees. Recently, one of our readers sent us a letter about facing this exact situation at her law office.
The letter:
Hi Bright Side,
I (26, F) have been working at the same law office for almost a year.
Sunday, 10 a.m.: I woke up to a call from HR: a huge pipe had burst, and our office was flooded. Rescuers secured the area, but HR wanted the team to come and evacuate confidential client files. They were calling me to handle the folders of the clients whose cases I’d been working on, some of which contained sensitive information.
I said, “I don’t work weekends. Sorry.” I hung up, thinking that was the end of it.
On Monday, I went in and found my entire desk empty. All of my belongings had been moved.
At first, I thought the office must have temporarily relocated because of the flooding, but when I called HR, things took a different turn.
I froze when they informed me that my contract with the firm would not be renewed.
They said they expect full commitment from their employees and that I hadn’t met their standards.
For the 10 months I worked there, I was a devoted employee.
I just believe that my weekends are not meant to be spent in the office, even in an emergency, but now I’m doubting my decision.
Was I wrong to refuse to go in and help with the folders?
Best regards,
Elaine

There are exceptions to every rule and this is one situation where an exception should have been made and you should have gone in since this was a true emergency.
I used to think I could never earn more than what my previous employer paid me — but I was wrong. The world is full of opportunities for those willing to take a chance.
Now, I’m earning $52 per hour or more, and I can easily make at least $1,300 a week. Based on my experience, I believe everyone should try working online — it’s a simple and flexible way to earn money. Here's an example:
Www.Richnow1
100% wrong..my grandma told me many decades ago, the best way to go thru life is to be flexible, treat people how you want to be treated, and find something to smile about every day..
Every place I worked over my lifetime, they knew they were getting 99% of my capabilities..I cross trained, I worked weekends, overnight shifts, and at one point in time, I worked three part time jobs as there were no full time jobs in the mid 1980's..the Reagan years..
I never once would have ever dared to act in such a way, ever! That is subordination, which is a legal reason to terminate anywhere you go..
You need to grow up
That’s actually insubordination and is a fireable offense. What you were doing was subordinate.
It was an emergency for Pete's sake! If you were out of town and unavailable that would be different. But your response that you don't work on the weekend even for an emergency shows you are inflexible and not a team player. You messed up. Hopefully you learn from this.
I wonder how many of these arrogant, negative replies would be the same if a man did this? Few...that's how many. In today's environment, no one should be forced, coerced, or quilted into working on their day off. Maybe she has children or an aging parent at home and doesn't have weekend help? So much bs...
And maybe when a act of god occurs and there is a emergency, you make arrangements and fix it, bc no one could have planned for the pipe bursting? Id say the same even if this was a guy
Big deal, 10 months and you couldn't go in for an office emergency to remove important files. Files I'm sure keep you employed in the first place.
Exactly the reason you were fired, it wasn't asked every weekend, it's the same emergency you would hope someone in the office might help you out and take your case load while you have an emergency
Hope you find a job that doesn't require any extra effort
As this was a one time emergency and the actual work requested was on confidential files that you had been working on, Id have agreed. If you were somewhere that made attending impossible, I d have politely said this and asked if there was anything I could do remotely if possible. Obviously, if circumstances made this impossible I would have stated that, too. "Sorry, I'm in Vegas for a friends birthday. My flight isn't for 2 hours. Can I do anything to help by phone?" Or " I'm at the hospital. I tripped playing baseball and probably fractured my ankle. I'm pretty woozy from pain meds and can't really walk, so I don't think that I can help. Sorry. " if it was like most of the places I've worked that seem to think that I should be honored to come work some unpaid overtime because " Sandra called in sick " or" Joey never showed up ", I wouldn't even answer my phone.
So Where was the company emergency plan and was it communicated out to staff at onboarding. The company does not own you 24/7 because they pay you a wage! What if you were out of town, in hospital or other wise indisposed? Would they have paid you? Is it in your job description? What if you got hurt doing this clean up work?
Wow. They were having an emergency and you couldn't help out? I would fire you also!
In times of emergency we all go above. YES you should have gone into the office and secured YOUR files. They were CONFIDENTIAL files. Your clients trusted you to keep their information CONFIDENTIAL.
Your files? Your Clients? Don't you mean the company file and clients. The clients trusted the company NOT the individual
This is a counterfeit, bogus person. A hospital or provider farmed out billing too a third party. A class action is now being process to sue. Meanwhile they have the gall too tell me what I can do...
Given that this was an emergency and they asked that everyone, not just you, show up to help, you should've stepped up without hesitation. I know I would've rushed over to do what I can, not to get praise from anyone but to lessen the burden on everyone there.
Yes. Setting boundaries can be important, especially if your boss was always trying this. But this was an emergency situation with confidential client files that could cause the firm to be sued. So I would have fired you too. You may sit at your desk and do your work, but when they really needed you, you did not help pull your weight.
In the 10 months you have worked there how many times have they called you on the weekend. What would you do if a client had a major legal issue that had to dealt w RIGHT now. You deserved to be fired.
I look at it like this. If it was a lack of planning, nope I am not available. Sounds like pipes bursting is both unplanned and an emergency. I picked a career where I am willing to come in for a real emergency and I am compensated for it in one form or another.
Many people especially management think their employees and others managers or supervisors should be committed to the job. No because management will get rid of anyone at any time they want to. You could be hardworking, never called out or come in late. Who do you put first? God, your family or your job. Do you want to be that person who worked all their life and later find out that job you devoted all your time with will get rid of you and not support you when you need them. That happens to so many people. Besides you don't know that individual circumstances or why they need to be home on the weekends.
My friend here is the truth. You did nothing wrong. The company should had made an offer to you so it would be a one time thing. This way once you came in for that emergency your company would not do it again. Taking advantage of you. Because once you do come in they will always bring up why you don't work on weekends had no weight .Believe me I have seen this happen to many times working in management. Not all upper management will honor their employees request or their availability when it comes to their circumstances. Know this first hand . You need to find another employment. Most employer will make demand on you they would not do. Know this first hand. Jobs come and go. And most will get rid of you for anything even if you are a good employee. I always put my family first and when one of my employees needed time off and I know they cannot work on weekends or a certain day of the week. I honor it .
What crap
No you where not wrong. It was management job to secure the files until Monday. That's why they get paid the big bucks. What if you were out of town or had a hangover. Would they still have wanted you to come in ??? And would you have been paid overtime for coming in on a weekend ??? The company is just mad because they now know you have strict boundaries and can't make you come in on your days off. Because what could have actually been done that couldn't have waited until Monday.
Annnd this is why you need to work in some other industry. Pipe bursting in an office is Management's problem. Did they not image all their files? When was this, 1996??
It's a law office, they have paper files too.
Some fields of work require both paper and electronic files. You are correctShe needs it for work in the field that has no expectations.And pay, that is appropriate to a no expectation.Job
Absolutely wrong. It was an emergency and I would imagine there were many people there on their time off helping to rescue important things. If you believe one years worth of service to your job means your entitled to say no when something like that happens, I don't know what planet you've been employed on previously.
You should have said "I'll come in but if i have an emergency on my end in the future, i expect equal understanding when i need to leave work early or skip a day." This puts the ball back in their court and if they turn out to be assholes about it then that's on them, not you.
I agree with the first half of your statement. The second have that conversation needs to be had at another time, emergencies happen plain and simple. This isn't something that's done all the time.This isn't them taking advantage.These were client aisles was sensitive information that it could have put her company in her at risk.Had they not been dealt with immediately. She's either part of a team or she needs to find a job that she only needs to take care of herself.There are a lot of dishwashing jobs open
Hindsight is 20/20. Your decision did cost you your job but you are the only one that could make that decision. When I was much younger I would jump every time my employer said to. Now at 65 and a few life lessons, I would have said I am out of town on a family emergency. I will be back late Sunday. Should I check with you then? Of course the answer would be no but you offered anyway. See how you saved your job and your weekend.
Soapy, in the approximate same age as you are.I have also learned lessons.I would have asked for what my expectations were outside of business hours.Is the employee salaried, or is she hourly. But teaching her to be dishonest in her answers instead of asking these questions at the time of an interview is wrong.Because you couldn't tell the truth and say no or have the appropriate conversations.You should not teach other people to lie
Call a plumber for broken water pipes
CorrectBut the plumber can't take care of files with sensitive material in them. How would you feel that will your file?And it got into the wrong hands.The company did absolutely the right thing.By having only those that were qualified to handle those confidential files and asking them to come in to take care of them.It's a freak accident, apparently.We, as a sight, have forgotten that we could give a little.
Lmao only 10 months, never go in on your day off but calls yourself devoted. Probably spends a lot of time at the start of your shift just settling in and from the lack of effort and laziness you probably never worked a single minute past your shifts scheduled time in your life. What is wrong with this generation. YTA
You know what, Lizzy? I am 38. I have worked a lot of jobs. I have been the dedicated employee who stayed late, went in early, was willing to go in at the drop of a hat if the boss called. If you're salaried...fuck going in on your time off...most employers fuck over salaried workers so that their salary equals the pay of the hourly employees whom they manage...and then sue the Department Of Labor when they make a rule requiring that salaried workers be paid overtime unless they are in executive positions. If you're hourly, fuck the employer for firing you for refusing to work during hours you weren't scheduled. You have a valid wrongful termination case here whether or not they like it. You go in for ONE emergency and suddenly they'll have you working every weekend because a client feels like something needs done by Monday even if it isn't that important. The OP did the right thing. Shut off the water main...lock file cabinets and offices where files were kept. Move any files from areas where the main has caused damage and has to be reached. Lock those files in a file cabinet or desk in an unaffected office. Call a plumber. There is absolutely ZERO need for everyone to come in. That pipe in the bathroom or wherever absolutely DOES NOT run through every single office wall in the building. Sue for wrongful termination and take them for every penny you can!!
You were wrong, period.
Lmao said like an absolute loser. Inbet you anything hr wasn't out there getting a bunch of folders.
Projection.
Yes. Saying " What? Ph my goodness,.a pipe burst? Yes, of course I'll come in and secure the folders and help out! On my way!" would have bought you their courtesy and understanding when you have an emergency on a weekday.
Said like a moron that actually thinks a company is a family and has your back. They don't therefore we don't owe them anything.
Said unemployed Kris, wondering why they don't have a job.
I absolutely disagree with your comment.
Regarding the previous answer. There is definitely a balance between always being taken advantage of and also being selfish.And never pitching in . Whether this is a family atmosphere or not.She said those were her confidential files that she handled at work.This isn't something that happened to her every weekend.They had never called her in before.And they had an emergency with files that should not be in just anyone's hands that had private information in them.She absolutely should have come in and helped. Not all companies take advantage and yes, you do owe your company. Some consideration. You my dear will not go very far.Because you're probably an all or nothing girl.And my guess is eight nothing girl
You can't just expect that without saying it.
Your time is yours those company's will bleed you dry if you let them if you go in once on the weekend they will expect and consume your life. That's why its called a weekend files are always backed up nothing is ever lost next time get a separate work phone and leave it in the drawer under the keys on silent
That is not why they call it a weekend. So what everyone is supposed to have the weekend off? Yeah imagine wanting to go to the movies or the mall or grocery store but they're close because "weekend" I stg these incels with less than 2 braincells make me dumber with every comment I read.
You make no sense
When you had a personal emergency during work hours, do you expected them to give you a time off?
For sure. My employer does
This is the first and only time they have called in ten months, and it was an emergency.And it was to remove files that she had access to.Because some companies asked for paper and electronic files and that information shouldn't have been for anybody to have access to.It was a one time deal.She could have had conversations afterward regarding what her expectations were, which, by the way she should have had.When she started the job.Yes, there are companies who will bleed you dry.But this doesn't appear to be one of them, they didn't come.And ask her to catch up on the project.They didn't come in at.They didn't ask her to come in.And cover somebody who didn't show up, they had a pipe burst. I can tell you're going to go far in this world
Yta. They said the pipes burst and they needed to recover sensitive client docs. Those clients had faith in you and it was an emergency
Exactly! If I hurt for her client, and they found that was her attitude.I would be looking for different representative.
YTA...not a team player, I guess. This was an emergency. The same company you were stuffing in an emergency was the same company you would expect to allow you preferential treatment in YOUR emergency, ie. time off due to medical emergency, flooding in your home, death in the family. Your next employer should be made aware by you that you do not deviate from your hours or job description. Should make interviews pretty interesting.
Exactly. Not a team player. Could have gone in for a couple hours at time and a half off for another day .
Yes as a matter of fact you were. Emergencies happen. Especially in the workplace on weekends. You should have gone into the office to assist anyway. The fact that you didn't go shows that you don't really care about helping others out when the situation calls for it. That's very irresponsible on your part and yes if I worked in management and you had that attitude I wouldn't hire you either.
Facts, she's probably just a paralegal with lack of effort or laziness. But imagine she's the lawyer and it's a time sensitive case going over details on Friday at 4:59 and she just cuts you off and say bye I'll see you Monday I don't work past outside my scheduled hours and lose the case because of another 1 of these lazy degenerates that can't work a functioning job properly. I stg covid and work from home made this generation so weak to putting in actual effort and they just want to get paid for not doing any work
The first thing wrong is, “she’s probably just a paralegal.” A comment you would not make if the OP was male. The second is assuming she is lazy or won’t work a minute past 5 pm.
Despite your glaring bias against an entire generation who has been smart enough to set professional boundaries, I think the OP was wrong under these circumstances. This was not a manufactured crisis or due to a lack of planning among higher ups. Clients personal information should be held in the utmost regard so it was imperative everything was secured.
It also sounds like a real all hands on deck. If OP had just gone in, she would have had an opportunity to see who else was there. If partners were rolling up their sleeves and working as hard as assistants it would say a lot about the firm as would the opposite.
I can calmly agree with you on this point for sure...but at the same time...most offices have locking file cabinets and a pipe bursting wouldn't have affected files in every office...just those near the breach. As standard practice, lawyers and their employees lock their files whenever they are not in the office. They also keep electronic copies on computers. They could have reprinted the ones affected on Monday and not called ANYONE in on the weekend. Shut off the water main, lock the file cabinets and any unaffected offices, then call a plumber. Standard DOD SCIF procedure...secure all files and computers when people without security clearances are working in your area.
Yes you were definitely wrong made yourself look like a bitch that cares nothing for the business I would of let you go too
Yes you were. It was an emergency. Be a team player!! You showed you are not committed to your employer. It was an emergency and they needed help
Yea you were wrong not to go in, only because it was an emergency. If a pipe burst in your house, would you accept a plumbers excuse of “ I don’t work weekends”? You should have gone in to assist. That just made you look like an uncaring, disconnected part of the team. If I were management, I would have let you go too
You were wrong. It was your job and your company called on you in a crisis. What sort of employee are you?
Lawyers are kinda essential. Those folders are ride or die some more literal depending on your cases. You can't walk into court and go sorry your honor, all that information was destroyed but a flood but I swear my client should get everything he wants, honest!!
I would be greatly disappointed if she is actually a lawyer, from the sounds of her actions of lack thereof at best she's either a paralegal or secretary in the law firm
Some careers? Sure, don’t work weekends.
A Law Firm? Honey, never work in Law again. I personally wouldn’t hire you.
Well obviously... You were dead wrong.
1. It was an unforseen circumstance
2. Emergency
3. Your clients confidential files...
What did you expect???
I would hate to be your client... Jeez.
Plus she doesnt say that she was away for the weekend. Seems like she was just planning on chilling at home but was too lazy to give a hand at the office.
Yeah, you messed up big time. Not a team player. Good luck finding another job especially when they check your references.
How much is your time worth? With your kids, whats it worth.... you have a slave labor mentality of the 60"s. My personal time is worth 4x more then my salary... and I will never give time to a corporation that would let me go at the drop of a hat... it's like the 2 week notice thing... does your employer give you 2 weeks notice before they fire you? Basically you can be the idiot. Let others do what they feel they should do for themselves.
I would agree if the OP had a job where 80 hours a week were considered the norm or management always pushed for weekends and late nights with no consideration for their employees needs. This was a one time emergency. As a client I would be disappointed to know some employees could not be bothered to secure my sensitive date under these circumstances.
Then don't go to work if your time is so valuable.
You do not need to have a slave labor mentality of six of the sixties, but this wasn't them.Asking her to go consistently at the drop a hat, and it's difficult to give a two weeks notice.When a pipe bursts and confidential information and files that she was entrusted with are compromised. Yes, my time is valuable when I am at home.However, there are circumstances where I would be needed that I can go help just as if there are circumstances when I need help.My company is also very cognizant and willing to reciprocate. In this case, she was wrong.And this has nothing to do with the sixties mentality of overwork
Yes. You were wrong. This was a one time event. You won't have a flood every day. You are not someone they can count on in an emergency. It's called a surge and you were a no show.
Okay, if they were calling you I'm because they wanted you to work a full 8 hr normal shift on your day off. If say fuck em too. But this isn't an ordinary call in. This isnt so.ething they'll take advantage of week after week because you gave them an inch one time. It's an unforseen catastrophic event that is important for the company to function. In which case it's perfectly reasonable to expect an all hands on deck attitude from HR. The quicker shit gets done the less likely sensitive data will be damaged and less likely for clients to be concerned or turned away. This a career, not a summer job at Walmart where they're constantly taking advantage of their employees. OP had an opportunity to prove herself and bot only squandered it but outright proved she was unreliable. Yet she acts like they interrupted her weekend so she could fetch the boss' coffee for him. And while I'd be willing to say not showing up is appropriate if say, you were at a funeral or a wedding in which making your excuses would rather strongly impact your personal life I'd at least explain, give them a time where you'd be available, and try to cut out asap. Or if you were taking a weekend away in another city. In which case you already likely spent hundreds to get there why should you be expected to spend hundreds or thousands to go back for a few hours without even doing what you came to do. Especially if it's hours away drive or requires a ferry/plane to return. Money don't grow on trees and as it's a new job it's unlikely OP could easily afford that. Unless the company offered to reimburse.
What an idiot. This is why no one wants to hire “Gen Z”. It’s because of this mindset. Never willing to do extra. Glad she got her contract terminated. Serves her right. Maybe next time she’ll think twice. “I just believe that my weekends are not meant to be spent in the office, even in an emergency.” That says it all. This was a one time thing and she couldn’t even go help out. Then the way she answered the phone, “not coming in. Sorry.” It should have been, “I’ll be there as soon as I can.”
Another dumb shit comment from a stay at home mom with all the entitlement, and no life experiences. The fact you went to Gen z is really telling....
Maybe because in this scenario it was appropriate.
Or dont answer phone. Sorry. I was in the woods & had no service. Just got this how can I help
Hmm yes another Gen Z trying to defend the other incapable worker. Lying to cover up the laziness is just as bad. I hate your generations laziness and incomoetence
Harry is right. People have a life outside of work and weekends aren't meant to be spent in offices, emergency or not
So, you live at work now? You are mostly right though, but it's entirely dependent on what kind of lawyer she is; if she's an actual proper lawyer, not a paralegal, then you're exactly right. You MUST come in for those files, especially with that kind of confidentiality.
So then, when the OP has an emergency on a weekday.... a burst pipe, a car breakdown, last minute tickets to a concert...... the company is fully justified in telling the OP too bad, fix it on the weekend.
Actually...if she's a lawyer...they probably do...continuances in court cases don't grow on trees...judges will only grant them a certain number of times before it becomes 'too bad...work with what you have'.
I disagree, sometimes it has to be given take in a balance between work and at home.There are real emergencies and those that happen every weekend from the sound of the email.This is the first time in almost a year.She was asked, and it wasn't to clean up.It was to come and take care of confidential folders that were entrusted to her. I do not understand this all or nothing.Mentality, you want all and give nothing extra ever
Perhaps your bias is why Gen Z is learning to hate boomers and whatever the next generation is. With comments like yours, can’t say I blame them a bit.
I do agree. The Gen. z remarks are inappropriate. Although there does appear to be a correlation, it's not necessary. A causation.
Or an excuse as to why people don't help in emergencies. Anymore, and it's not just work. Emergencies, it's any emergency.
In the last few years, people who stand around and see an accident.People who don't volunteer people who pretend they don't see what really happens.And I can say, this isn't just a generational thing for genz, I see us, babyboomer in millennials in other generations do it too. But your remark is just as bad as the one you are responding to
I don’t agree my comment was anything like the original. The same person has been spewing vitriol about Gen Z all over the comments. Perhaps the pendulum has swung a little too far but I’m glad to see a new generation questioning employer practices previous generations tolerated. They are being asked to go above and beyond at a time when jobs are cut on a whim and the wages have been stifled to the point we made more in the 1980s while working a lot less hours. Even we of the older generations did our share of pushing back on sexism and racism in the workplace which is why it’s so different now than in 1960 or even 1990.
However, you are right about this, it’s not just a generational issue. Entitlement these days knows no age limits.
Popesmom, just so you know, "boy mom", "coaches wife," and "military wife" are not job tites.
Honestly, she wasn’t wrong at all. It’s not her responsibility to show up on her day off just because the company failed to prepare for an emergency. The firm should’ve had protocols in place for that. Her job is to do her work during her scheduled hours — not to sacrifice her personal time to save them from their own lack of planning. Firing her just shows how toxic that ‘devotion culture’ really is.”
How exactly does someone prepare for a burst pipe and resulting flood? I worked in offices for years and never once had it happen. Files need to be accessible, and yes that includes physical copies, AND they need to be secure. Everyone seems to think this is about damage so data back up would suffice. There are two issues, some documents could be in their original form because they need to be certified. Even more important, the offices therefore the documents will not be secure while random workers are in and out during the clean up and repair. This means confidential client information could be exposed.
Actually, she was wrong, and so are you?She never once complained about her job being toxic and having a devotion, culture and many companies do have protocols.But I don't know of many who have protocols for busted pipes. This wasn't a requested, is repeatedly asked of her. It was a one time request that you could have addressed afterwards at a later time.
You both are wrong. Unfortunately, I know. Baby boomers such as myself were overworked and never said no. And were not paid enough for that. And we are appreciative of the fact that subsequent generations have recognized that and are looking for a balance between work and home. However, once in a while, there are emergencies at work and sometimes there are emergencies at home and a good employee. And a good employer work in order that the employer can help the employee and the employee can help the employer when these things happen. A successful company and a happy fulfilled worker know that a job is not black.And white, unless you sit home behind a computer and work that would probably be the only time or you never expected.Advance
You work at a LAW FIRM, so yes you should have gone to help, if only so that your clients don't have confidential information exposed. Did you really expect to still have a job when you flaked at a most unexpected but CRUCIAL TIME? EMERGENCIES are called that for a REASON. They didn't ask you to rewrite a motion or take a deposition, they asked you to help PROTECT CLIENT INFORMATION. The client is what pays your (non-existent now) salary. I hope you get smarter by the time you get another job.
Found the cuck
You're a jerk and should be fired from every job you've ever held for bot giving a rat's behind about rhe security of tour clients files.
You looking in mirror?
Cheryl, there are better ways to convey what you want to say. I hope you get smarter by the time you post again.
Ralph..do you really think Cheryl cares about your opinion? Your comment was judgy. I hope YOU get smarter by the time YOU post again. Hmmmmph.
hey, everyone commenting here was judging....or giving an opinion, which is what she was asking for. Take a chill pill.
Weird. Almost as much as you think I care about this one? You're doing the same thing I did lol
I mean you cared enough to reply so you clearly do give a $hit
I do do. I care.
Thank You Christy. I am more than willing to take, CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM, but being insulted by this Dbag named Ralph is getting old. Have a blessed day.
Nothing wrong with your original comment, it's just these weak generation can't face the truth and hides behind saying mental health whenever they can't take accountability for anything and falter whenever it comes to challenges in life
You're doing the same thing as Ralph haha
I have come to expect the drivel that you respond to me with, so keep on bro, I get my best laughs from you 🤣
I find it funny that all the reply are from women that do nothing but Karen others....
It's me. I'm that person 🤣
100%
Well, let's see, the responses we are making are requested by the OP and are directly related to the story. You, again, like a few others out there are disparaging us for giving intelligent and sensible replies to the question asked by the OP. So if you want to RESPOND TO THE STORY, please do so. Insulting the responders is a sign that you are not intelligent enough to give a cogent and useful answer, or you are only capable of insults. If I am wrong, I will certainly apologize to you, but you would have to prove it to me.
Actually...most offices have secure filing cabinets and safes. Risk of damage to the files is normally minimal due to the bottoms of filing cabinets normally having a 1-3 inch base before you get to the bottom of the bottom drawer. If the military can have a Plan Of Action in place to keep classified information secure when an emergency happens that requires uncleared civilians to come in and fix things...civilians (who are normally much smarter) should have one in place much faster. Besides...who said that her office and files were affected by the burst pipe? Not every office would be affected by it...especially if it's a multiple floor building. If you can't say for sure that MY files ARE or WILL be affected... don't expect me to come in. Call the people whose files ARE or WILL be affected...rather than wasting everyone's time calling everyone in when they don't have keys to anyone else's shit.
You are missing the point completely. The chance that ANYONE'S INFORMATION could be lost WAS THE POINT. It is A LAW OFFICE , and ANY chance of compromising any clients information, could be detrimental to that firm. If they asked her to come in on EVERY WEEKEND then, of course she would have an issue. You and I have NO IDEA what was needed but it was an emergency, so it was an ALL HANDS ON DECK SITUATION. You are trying to split hairs here, but it is not working.
Thank you, Elaine, for sharing your story with us. We understand how frustrating it must feel to give your best for months only to face this kind of setback.
Your experience raises important questions about work expectations and personal limits, and we’ve prepared some advice that may help you move forward.
Acknowledge the Difference Between “Work” and “Emergency”

Working at a place 10 whole months faithfully was put to an abrup test and this person failed miserably.
An emergency means extenuating circumstances, not every weekend.
I'd have fired their butt too.
Maybe being a barista somewhere with little responsibilities is a better fit.
You didn’t refuse a routine weekend assignment — you refused an emergency tied to client security. In law, protecting confidential files isn’t just “extra work,” it’s a core responsibility.
Action: For future roles, clarify with your employer how emergencies are handled. That way, you’ll know in advance when you’re truly off duty and when extraordinary circumstances require stepping in.
Reframe This as a Learning Opportunity, Not Just a Loss

How would you like it if your house was on fire, but the firemen said "we're sorry, but we don't work on weekends"? This was an emergency, and it sounds like you had no urgent reason why you couldn't go help, even for your own clients. I'd get rid of you if you worked for me, mainly because you lack commonsense.
Being let go feels brutal after months of dedication, but the lesson is clear: some industries expect 24/7 readiness.
Action: Use this experience as a filter. Look for firms or companies that clearly respect work-life balance in their policies. By asking targeted questions during interviews, you can avoid repeating the same mismatch.
Repair Your Reputation Before Moving On
Law is a small world, and word spreads quickly. Right now, colleagues might see you as “the one who refused to protect client files.”
Action: Reach out to a trusted mentor or supervisor from the firm. Explain calmly that your refusal was about protecting your personal time, not a lack of respect for client confidentiality. Even if the contract isn’t renewed, this may preserve references you’ll need later.
Build an Emergency Response Strategy for Yourself
You value weekends, but emergencies will pop up again in any demanding field.
Action: Decide in advance where you draw the line — for example, “I’ll respond if it’s a one-off crisis tied to client safety, but not for routine weekend work.”
Having a personal plan avoids hesitation and helps you respond in ways that won’t backfire professionally.
Another reader chose not to join a weekend team-building trip, and her choice led to an unexpected response from HR. Check out her story here.
Comments
Yta, for the reason that it was a bonafide emergency! A burst water pipe can do as much damage as a raging fire in terms of destroying property. Yes, files can be backed up, but in the legal profession, hard copies are king! All HR was asking of you is for help preserving CASE FILES, which are crucial for defending your clients; they were NOT asking you to prepare depositions for a case! By dismissing your firm's plight, you proved that you couldn't be relied on for your clients, so that's why you got shown the door! Now you have to start from scratch all over again, and good luck trying to get a referral from your former employer!
I'm assuming you haven't been working for too long in the field. Ten months is not all that long. There are always positives to be found in any situations. A few simple questions could help you gauge the seriousness of the situation. If you suggest you're in the middle of something you can't leave right now but will be available in two hours it suggests willingness to help while also understanding what's going on. They might reply with 'thanks, but we'll have it sorted by then' or 'is there no way you can get back to your event later? The files will be lost and it could cost xyz his court case'. From there you quickly evaluate what you are willing to do, and also potentially face repercussions. After all it seems this was the first such call in ten months, right?
You are 100% in the wrong. I am assuming you are an attorney with the firm. As such you have an ethical duty to protect tour clients information as well as to work the hours needed to provide competent legal services. Yes, this sometimes includes weekends. You dont get to say nope not working this weekend to meet this filing deadline, nope not securing my clients confidentially.
In fact you are ALWAYS on the job to protect confidentially.
You very much picked the wrong profession to have this attitude and this is from an attorney who doesnt work evenings and in almost 20 years of practice has worked like 4 Saturdays
YTA. You work in a highly regulated industry. Your company would be in deep kimchi if those records were destroyed. It’s a good thing you weren’t personally legally reliable as well.
I'm of two minds about this. If the employer takes and takes and takes without adequate compensation, then, yes, by all means any employee is within their rights to enforce boundaries regarding working outside of their assigned hours.
However, if this is a one off situation where the employer is desperately looking for emergency assistance and you as an employee are relatively near by and capable of helping, why wouldn't you? At the very least, it would project a positive image and show you care about the clients. And I am sure you would have been paid for your time. Ah, well, it was a lesson learned.
Related Reads
I Refused to Let My SIL Bring Her Service Dog to My Wedding—and Now I’m the Villain

I Refused to Work During Lunch—My Boss’s Response Shocked Everyone

17 Hotels That Got 5 Stars for Their Creativity in Causing Problems

13 Mysterious Coincidences That Defied All Logic

I Begged My Family to Help With My Medical Bills—Their Response Left Me Stunned

My Coworker Saw My Posts Online—Now HR Is Calling Me In

My MIL Tried to Control My Wedding—So I Turned the Tables

My Son Thought I’d Be His Free Driver—But I Refused to Waste My Retirement

12 Times Kindness Won Over Anger in the Best Way

13 Stories Proving That Female Solidarity Turns Ordinary Women Into Legends

14 People Who Learned the Shocking Truth About a Friend

10 Real Life Twists That Could Make Hitchcock Wince


