My DIL Said I Wasn’t "Family"—So I Served a Payback She Won’t Forget

Family & kids
2 days ago

I never imagined I’d be the one kicked out, watching “family time” happen without me. But when my daughter-in-law drew the line and left me out, I made a quiet but powerful decision. And trust me—she won’t forget it anytime soon.

Hi Bright Side! I’m Nora, and this is something that’s been weighing on my heart. Let me share my story.

When my son, Ethan, married Lena three years ago, I truly welcomed her as part of the family. I saw her as the daughter I never had. I have always supported my son and DIL. I lent them money, cooked, and babysat whenever they asked. I never kept score—I just thought that’s what families did for one another.

But clearly, Lena doesn’t see “family” the same way I do.

Imagine being so insecure that you can't handle the fact that your daughter-in-law may want to have dinner with her parents and siblings without you every now and then.
That's just bizarre and sad.

-
-
Reply

The day I realized I’m not “family”.

Just last week, Ethan mentioned they were planning a “family dinner” at their place. I smiled and quickly offered to help and bring dessert. But, my DIL looked me in the eye and said, “Oh, you’re not invited because it’s just going to be my parents and siblings this time.”

I blinked, unsure if I heard her right. “But... aren’t I immediate family?”

In all honesty if the MIL wasn't to be invited it shouldn't have been mentioned to her. The DIL could have said thank you for offering maybe next time since this time we're going to have just my side of the family instead of starting with 'You're not invited' There is no reason why son and DIL, son and grandbabies can't spend time with other family members. YOU sound like a toxic MIL

-
-
Reply

You're making the assumption that the mother-in-law is being honest about what was said and what actually went down.

-
-
Reply

Wow!! Her immediate family are HER parents and siblings!! Believe it it not, they can have a dinner without inviting you!! Geesh!!

-
-
Reply

She gave me a tight-lipped smile. “We just wanted to keep it simple—with my side of the family.”

I was stunned. After everything I had done for them, I was being treated like some distant acquaintance. I helped them move into that house, helped decorate that dining room—yet I wasn’t good enough to sit at their table?

So, I responded quietly—but effectively.

She stated right off the bat that it was a family dinner with her family 'for a change'. Why does it sound by your own admission and your astonishing leap for dessert even with' my parents and siblings ' being stated, that you insert yourself at any and every opportunity into their lives. And you ' just stopped tolerating . . . tolerating what, them cutting off allowing you over access to their lives at every turn?' I can't help but notice you quoted her as saying it was going to be her parents and siblings ' for a change' for the planned dinner, that definitely sounds like your family is over for dinner a lot more than hers but you never actually mention any of your family till the very end, you seem to be the only person you consider. She has family too remember, and hers is just important in the scheme of things. I'd love to know why you insist on your nose being so far out of joint because you aren't invited this time, you are family but you aren't her side of the in laws. I think it's called narcissism when you consider yourself to be the only person of consequence in the world. You could have been normal and loving and said' Oh that will be so nice for you all ' but you turn it to a b**thurt ' but I'm family too ' and then play poison pen because you got excluded from 1 event. If you thought to garner support for yourself with this I think you miscalculated cuz you come off making yourself sound a touch unbalanced, like there was always a possibility they could have looked out a window any night to see you playing peeping tom. They weren't asking you to be a second class citizen in their lives, or cutting you off, they just wanted to be with the other side of the family for the evening. Congratulations, this kinda stinker will take time to heal if it ever does. Apologize would be a good start. You come off sounding more like a 3rd grade girl being jealous of her friends having other friends than a grown a** woman living her best life, I picture the words ' but she was mean to me' with a whine coming out of your mouth in conversations on the subject but you kinda deserved a comeuppance for copping such an attitude over this one event, I don't care if you loaned them millions in their time of need, it doesn't give you exclusivity to their family and all you can ever hope to do without an apology and an effort to be more considerate of what they need of family time is to drive them farther away. You overstepped so many unwritten in-law rules ( like maybe dropping over uninvited and unannounced at inappropriate times thus the dinner warning in the first place? ) and I'm pretty sure your son has been anything but blind to it for a while.

-
-
Reply

At first, I did what most moms would—I cried in the laundry room and scrubbed the floors until I couldn’t feel the sting anymore. But that night, I remembered something important: Lena had once asked me for a favor.

A few weeks earlier, Lena had requested a reference letter for a job at a well-regarded private school. She said they valued strong family support systems, and she’d even mentioned how close we all were during her interview prep. She asked me to “talk her up a bit” if anyone contacted me.

So, I decided to send a short, sincere email to the school’s hiring committee.

I wrote:
“Lena is truly dedicated and works so well with children. She’s spoken often about how important family is to her, and we’ve shared many lovely moments—although it’s been a while since we last had a family dinner together. Wishing you the best with your hiring decision!”

No insults. No drama. Just facts—with a little context.

We had a falling out.

Two days later, Lena found out the school had selected another candidate. And the very next morning, she came to my home in full fury.

“You deliberately ruined this for me!” she snapped.

I calmly replied, “I told the truth, Lena. You claimed we were close, but then you turned around and excluded me. I didn’t say anything bad—I just let them know it’s been a while since we’ve shared a family moment. You painted one picture; I provided a more honest one.”

Ethan stood behind her, silent. Maybe he agreed with her. Maybe he didn’t. But he didn’t speak up, and that silence said a lot.

Things are cold now. There are no more fake pleasantries. Lena and I don’t pretend anymore. And sadly, we don’t see each other much at all. My husband, Mark, thinks I should extend an olive branch—that I should be the bigger person and reach out. But here’s the thing: I didn’t start this. I just stopped tolerating it.

I still miss the idea of family dinners, of being included, of being respected. But I don’t miss feeling like a second-class member of my own son’s life.

Would you have done the same? Or should I be the one to make peace first?

A woman revealed why she chose to stop paying her DIL’s medical bills in our previous letter. Read full story here: I Stopped Paying My DIL’s Medical Bills—I’m Not Her ATM Anymore.

Comments

Get notifications

Well, OK, OP you really stuck it to your DIL, so you should pat yourself on the back and feel smug. Now your son and DIL have the Ace to play ... them and your grandkids. Was it worth it to retaliate for a simple visit with her family? You may have won that battle, but guess who has all the cannons to use in the war you declared?

-
-
Reply

I kept my granddaughter for 5 years and I enjoyed every moment. I help my daughter's family when I can, but guess what, she can still entertain in her home without me. She's an adult.

-
-
Reply

Nope! Without knowing the complete story that one sentence would not have made a difference and the hiring process. Daughter-in-law is in the wrong for confronting her MIL.

-
-
Reply

This makes no sense. She didn't say someone from the school reached out to her for a reference, only that she wrote an email. O.K. And a family member as a reference? Ah.. unusual. Unless mil had a personal relationship with the recruiter, I call BS. But if it did happen, I bet this wasn't the first occasion she butted in to, which is why they said "this time".

-
-
Reply

She did not say you were not family she said they were doing dinner with just her side of the family. You got your feelings hurt for no good reason. You should have spoken to your son about your hurt feelings before acting out of spite. Now both of you have hurt feelings and lost trust in each other. Truth be told they should still be able to have private family time with both sides of the family without feelings being hurt and it doesn't mean that you aren't family or are less family. Think about how things could have been different if you would have been open about your feelings In the first place. They should have said that your daughter in-law needed time to feel still connected with her parents and a smaller family dinner is a better way to reconnect. I'm sure her family is not at every family meal you have had with them that doesn't mean that her side is less than family. I really feel that you maybe being more sensitive than needed and should analyze why you are feeling so insecure.perhaps you feel you do more for them than her family has is their some underlying resentment because of it

-
-
Reply

Related Reads

tptp