You would have no peace if you apologize, so don't. She was rude and incredibly disrespectful. Your husband made the right choice. You and your husband should quit calling and trying to reason with insanity. If the in-laws want to be a part of your child's life, let them figure it out and come to you with an apology and plan to make things right. I couldn't imagine speaking to anyone like that, let alone a pregnant woman. She sounds like an awful person.
Dear Bright Side,
My MIL and I never got along, but she lived a few states over and wasn’t overly involved, so it wasn’t as much of an issue. That was until the festive season rolled around and she insisted on visiting. I wasn’t a fan of the idea, but I couldn’t keep my husband from seeing his mother either.
So my MIL flew in for a Christmas celebration, and we went to pick her up at the airport. When she got to the car, she opened the passenger door where I sat, gave me a disgusted look, and demanded that I move so she could sit there.
I was 8 months pregnant, sitting in the passenger side of my car, and she had the nerve to say, “Move?” I couldn’t help but wonder if she was insane. So I refused and told her that she didn’t have any right to treat me like I was some second-class citizen.
Then she had the audacity to turn to my husband and snap, “Teach your wife some respect.” I was shocked and was preparing to defend myself. But then my husband got out and said, “My wife can’t respect anyone who doesn’t respect her first.”
Don't apologize! You did nothing wrong.
Your MIL is the one that needs to learn some respect.
If you weren't 8 months pregnant that would be a different story.
“How dare you?” my MIL asked, but my husband just motioned to the back door and asked if she’d be getting in or not. My MIL’s face turned bright red with rage, but she didn’t say another word. She just turned around and marched back to the terminal.
Twenty minutes later my husband got a text that said, “Staying at a hotel. Don’t bother coming by.” My husband tried calling, but she refused to have any contact with us at all. He recently reached out to my FIL because our baby was born, and he wants to set things right.
My FIL told my husband that my MIL is very upset and is demanding an apology because she feels we have disrespected her. So Bright Side, what do you think? Should we apologize to keep the peace? Or should I keep standing my ground?
Regards,
June M.
At least your husband stood up for you. Tell her she's not welcome anymore if she can't respect you and your life. Also tell her she won't see her grandchild until she can respect their parents
Technically I think it's called - your MIL is out of her ever loving mind (coincidentally is her 1st name Karen?). Congratulations, your husband is a keeper, and congratulations on your new family member.
MIL is the one who needs to apologise. How DARE she demand that you move from the passenger seat of your own car, just so she can sit there? You did the right thing by standing (or should that be sitting, lol?) your ground and refusing to move. Your husband also did the right thing by insisting his mother should sit in the back.
Se sounds like a control freak who needs to be put in her place.
You not your husband owe your Monster-in-law an apology. She disrespected you, your pregnancy and her own son. Even if you were to apologize what would it be for? Not to mention apology or not it will be held over your head for eternity!
Your MIL not speaking to you? Sounds like a win to me.
I think It Is the MIL Who Is in the wrong and should apologise.
You have no reason to apologize. If in laws want to be a part of your child's life they need to apologize and mean it. If MIL wants to pout, her loss and less stress on you. If she wants to come visit let her stay at an area hotel and she can take a shuttle to get there. Then you can go visit her there at your convenience.
I am so glad that your husband had your back. I was so afraid that he was going to be a mamas boy. Bit no, don't apologize. You did nothing wrong. But she should. It's probably for the best that she refuses to get over herself.
I wouldn't apologize you did nothing wrong.
I hate people who demand respect whilst treating others like dirt
Why should you apologise to someone who clearly doesn't respect you?
June, you already know the answer. SHE, HER, MIL can take a hike. Never doubt your actions towards silly little people. Stand strong. BUT its not over. Protect your family and congratulations on your new baby.
I think your Husband understands that You and your child are his family now. The MIL sounds like she got a completly legal humbling. There's nothing on your side to set right, other than to explain what happened to the FTL - because what the MIL would have said might have been blown out of proportion. Maybe he already knows. Maybe something more underlying going on with her and someone should just ask if she's ok?
Let granny pout. She is the one tripping!
The hell with her, good for you.
Tell her to PISS OFF. IF she wants to meet her grandchild, SHE can apologize for being a pushy bitch. IF NOT, no big loss. Lord knows what she might teach her grandchild some day.
Dear June,
Thank you for reaching out and sharing your story with us.
Don’t apologize for how you handled this. Apologize only if you’re willing to rewrite the reality of what happened. Your MIL didn’t ask for a seat. She demanded displacement from an 8-month-pregnant woman and then tried to enlist your husband to publicly put you “in your place.”
The key moment here isn’t her storming off. It’s your husband clearly, calmly backing you up without escalating. That sets a precedent you shouldn’t undo.
If you apologize now “to keep the peace,” you’ll be teaching her that she can disrespect you, walk away, and still be rewarded with contrition before the baby even arrives.
The only path forward that protects your family is a conditional reset: your husband can tell his father that you’re open to moving forward after his mother acknowledges that demanding respect while showing none was unacceptable.
No apology for refusing to move. No apology for boundaries. Peace built on submission won’t survive postpartum, sleep deprivation, or future visits anyway.
June’s husband proved whose side he’s really on, and that should provide her some comfort in this situation. What her MIL does next is out of her control. But she isn’t the only one with in-law struggles.
Another one of our readers reached out to share their experience. Read the full story here: My MIL Mocked Me at My Husband’s Birthday Party—I Gave Her a Brutal Reality Check.
What a rare treat! A husband who actually stands up for his wife in the face of disrespect!
June, do not apologize. Your MIL was the rude one and apologizing will only feed in to her delusion that she was wronged. If she wants to miss out on knowing her grandchild, that is on her.
However, if you feel bad for your husband's predicament, you could try having an honest conversation with your MIL. Tell that while you're not going to be her doormat or punching bag, you love her son and that's why you want to declare a ceasefire. This is contingent on her good, respectful behavior and both of you staying out of each other's way. This only works if she merely dislikes you and is not completely insane. If it is dislike, she may take your offer of a draw and quietly reintergrate herself in her son's life.
