I Refused to Babysit My Grandson for Free

Family & kids
4 days ago

At Bright Side, we often hear from readers who are dealing with tough family situations. One of our readers, Amanda, recently wrote to us to share her story. She explained why she made the difficult decision to say no when her daughter-in-law asked her to babysit her grandson every day—for free. Amanda’s story has sparked a lot of conversation about family roles, boundaries, and what it really means to help. Here’s what she had to say.

Amanda’s letter:

Hi Bright Side,

My DIL asked me to babysit my grandson every day because she’ll be spending extra time at work. I said, “I’m not a free daycare.” She left without saying a word.

The next day, I got a frantic call from my grandson in tears. I froze. To my utter shock, his mom had dropped him off at a daycare, gave them my number, and left. She told them to call me if he cried or needed anything.

He was so overwhelmed and lost in that place that he just kept crying. I couldn’t bear to hear him like that, so I went and picked him up.

Clearly, my daughter-in-law wanted to teach me a lesson—and it worked, this time. But I still won’t let myself be guilt-tripped into staying home all day, every day, just so she can earn more money and push her career forward.

Does that make me a heartless grandma?

Sincerely,
Amanda

This child has 2 parents. Where is YOUR SON? I would be afraid she would take him to work and leave him in the car all day or at home alone This child is in an unstable or dangerous situation .

-
-
Reply

Everyone failed in handling this situation. DIL needs to talk to MIL & ASK if she could help with childcare. MIL needs to consider the request & figure out what she’s able/willing to offer. Saying ‘I’m not a free daycare’ is rude & sounds like it’s all about money. Grandma should be willing to help her grandson - that’s what it’s all about. Giving him a loving, safe space to be cared for. DIL used her child by putting him in daycare & causing him unnecessary anxiety. Both are acting in selfish, spiteful ways. Adults involved are supposed to be looking out for the child & what’s best for HIM!! Grow up, ladies!

-
-
Reply

exactly. grandma cares more about $ than her grandchild. yet it is the DIL that is selfish ? i do agree, this situation could have been handled better by all parties. though i doubt this story is real.

-
-
Reply

Wow, are you guys entitled and clueless. Wait until you've worked your whole life, raised your kids and your creepy daughter in law says...sorry Cinderella you're still not done!

-
-
Reply

its hilarious you call grandma "Cinderella" in this context. but yes, when you choose to have a family the responsibility still continues even as grandparents. if more people realized this america in particular wouldnt have such severely dysfunctional family dynamics and an obsession with selfishness and individuality.

-
-
Reply

First off - what daycare allows a small child to make a phone call? And why did they allow him to be dropped off without both parents contact numbers?
I totally get that you don't want to be taken advantage of and you are right to feel this way. The DIL seems very entitled. What does your son think about all this?
Sorry but this story doesn't seem very realistic to me.

-
-
Reply

Why is it alright for the DIL to basically demand free daycare from her MIL? Are you kidding me? It's not Amanda's responsibility to provide daycare EVERY day for her grandchild.

Her DIL is selfish and very obviously manipulative. The fact that all of these commenters feel it's okay for the DIL to use her MIL like this is frankly shocking.

If the DIL was asking for occasional help I'm sure Amanda would have been pleased to help.
Grandparents are people with lives too...not free labour.

Ask yourselves why it's okay to vilify Amanda. She raised her children.

The DIL is wrong. You can't expect ANYONE to provide free labour for a full-time job. Grandchild or not.

Amanda, hold your ground.

-
-
Reply
2 days ago
Nothing will stay buried forever, apart from this comment.

Long Hours, is there something other than work that is causing the DIL to treat her child like an object to be dumped of on others.

-
-
Reply

plenty of grandparents babysit for free and that has been a standard practice in society until fairly recently. if you ask me this is indicitive of selfish behavior and is one reason among a laundry list that make child birth rates go down. if you cant even rely on your family to help you, what is even the point of having a family ? previous generations were lucky bc their parents were eager to babysit any new children. this society is not conducive to form a family in if every single thing has to become a financial transaction, even among your family. i would ice the MIL out honestly. especially since it sounds like she cares more about money than her grandchild.

-
-
Reply

It's mom and Dad's responsibility to raise their kids. What the DIL did was reckless and uncaring. Don't judge Grandma

-
-
Reply

I am the old generation, grandparents who watched full time were pitied. This DIL could at least help food and extras, so her application. DIL is selfish.

-
-
Reply
2 days ago
The comment was deleted by a neighbor's dog.
2 days ago
Can't find the comment? Ask your mom.
2 days ago
The comment has been disarmed.
2 days ago
Oops. The comment was captured by a UFO.

Your freaking kidding me?
I as a grandmother who takes care of her grandchildren and gets paid to do so, because this is my job and doing a job you get paid to do it. I stay home so that my grandchildren do not ever have to go to. Daycare, I don't ask for a lot of money. If they put them in daycare, it would be thousands of dollars. I charge $20 a day that aint nothing compared to what they pay in daycare, but I have to live too. I can go out and get a job and they can put that child in daycare or I can stay home. For $20 a day and be with my grandchildren. And help my family. There is nothing wrong with that. Just because we're Grand parents does not mean we're free babies sitters. Yes, weekends, while they go to a dinner or a movie or something like that? Yes free then. But if you're going to work and you're making money for work and we're staying home and watching the children isnt that my work, please explain your thought in that is that not work. We are not here to be free babysitters. While you work all day and sometime into the night We love out grandbabies asking to be paid to provide care is not wrong

-
-
Reply

my views on this may be different since i live with a woman that does babysit for free, albeit bc she can and doesnt have to worry about money. and im sure when you and your kids worked out the arrangement you didnt put money in the forefront of the conversation. by any chance did your parents ever charge you when you needed someone to babysit your kids ? im genuinely curious.

-
-
Reply
2 days ago
This comment got punished.

What about sharing time with the dil's mother? Why should only the mil be the responsible additional parent in this situation? Besides the dil could have gradually introduced her child to a daycare situation. She did both the grandson and the grandma wrong by just dropping him off and taking off.

-
-
Reply

It's her desperation to keep her job. If course she should involve her mother but what if the mother lived in a different state or country or city ? Hence let's be understanding.
The DIL needs help period

-
-
Reply

I don't know how the human societies of all over world work. However in our society there is a saying it takes a village to raise a child. we see raising a child as a whole family's duty. This duty we generally don't measure with money. We were raised and taught by our grand parents while our parents were busy earning or doing household work. That's how tradition flows from one generation to next generation.
If a child doesn't get enough love and affection from theirs parents grandparents and siblings, it not only affects his or her parents only but also his family and the community got affected. we also takes care of our aged grand parents alongwith our aged parents in our family and never leave them alone when they needed us the most.

-
-
Reply
2 days ago
The comment was deleted. Go home guys.

Babysitters cost $25 an hour. Tell the DIL, $100 up front, every day you want me to babysit, incidentals to be added when she picks the child up. And if the grandson calls the house again, talk to the childcare lady and tell *her*, call his mother and tell her to get her a** to school and pick your child up. Not my monkeys, not my circus.

-
-
Reply

And a qualified, background checked, credentialed, educated Nanny with over 30 years of experience like myself starts at no less than $30 an hour with benefits & a contract. I don't think very many Parents are researching enough (before they have children) the cost of a caretaker, unfortunately. I get plenty of work, but the amount of interviews & phone calls I have to go through of ppl telling me I'm "crazy" for my rates is kind of insane. Everyone is entitled to child care so they can work, but not everyone is entitled to private care in their home by a professional.

-
-
Reply
2 days ago
This comment came alive and ran away.

Yes, she is heartless to the core. Maybe, just maybe the daughter in-law wants to advance her career to get a better paycheck and not have to rely on her Heartless Mother in law. I feel sorry for the daughter in-law.

-
-
Reply

The DIL isn't entitled to grandma's time, especially if it's an every day thing. If DIL is taking more hours, she's making more money. She can pay to babysit, because contrary to popular belief. Kids aren't cheap.

-
-
Reply

If she would've thought of that before she got married and had a child this wouldn't have been an issue. She very much was taking advantage of her mother-in-law. The m.i.l. did the right thing by calling her out on it. If the d.i.l. winds up leaving her husband because of this then it's likely she was looking for an excuse to do it anyhow.

-
-
Reply

And it wasn't heartless to drop off the kid without giving Grandma a heads up? That little stunt made me lose any sympathy. DIL sounds very entitled

-
-
Reply

I babysit every chance I get. Everyday however would be way to much on my aging body. But if the child is say over 5 and doesn't need to carried around and diaper changes, I would gladly do all I can

-
-
Reply

Every chance you get! Before you know it, they're growing up and they don't need you anymore. You'll miss those days when they called you Nana or Grammy and wanted your attention.

-
-
Reply
2 days ago
This comment was too good to show it to everyone.

Hi Amanda! Thank you for sharing your story with us. We’ve prepared some guidance to support you as you work through this delicate situation.

Have a calm, direct conversation with your daughter-in-law.

Instead of letting tension build, ask your daughter-in-law to sit down for a private, respectful talk. Share how upsetting it was to receive that distressing call and explain that while you love your grandson, being cornered into caregiving isn’t fair.

Let her speak too—she may be feeling overwhelmed, even if her actions were wrong. A conversation like this can prevent emotional manipulation and keep your grandson from getting caught in the middle.

Offer a compromise schedule that works for you.

Rather than saying no outright, propose a schedule that allows you to help without sacrificing your freedom. Maybe you babysit twice a week or do school pickups—on your terms.

This protects your time while still giving your grandson some consistency and comfort. It also signals that you care, just not in a way that burns you out.

Loop your son into the discussion—privately.

I never turn down an opportunity to have my grandson. I can't relate to this at all.

-
-
Reply

Have a one-on-one with your son to share how things unfolded, especially how distressed your grandson was. He may not realize the emotional toll this situation took on you—or on his child. This gives him a chance to mediate or support a more respectful arrangement going forward.

Sometimes men underestimate how intense or emotional childcare negotiations can become, and your perspective might open his eyes. He might also help set clearer expectations between you and your daughter-in-law, which she might receive more calmly if coming from him.

Draw a clear line between love and obligation.

Well, I thought of it more as getting to spend time with my grandbabies , but if you see it as a chore requiring payment don't be surprised if he's too busy to help you unpaid with yardwork or whatever when he's older .

-
-
Reply

Remind both yourself and your family that loving your grandson deeply doesn’t mean sacrificing your time and boundaries. You’re not heartless—you’re protecting your own well-being while still wanting the best for him.

Framing it that way can help them understand that support is different from servitude. And your grandson needs a happy, willing grandma—not a resentful one.

Another Bright Side reader wrote to us after refusing to take her pregnant daughter-in-law to the hospital — here’s why.

Comments

Get notifications

When I picked him up I'd have told the daycare "Here's mom and Dad's phone #. Unless I give you permission to call me you don't have it." What a nasty Dil. Demanding 10+ hours a day, 5 days a week, for nothing.

-
-
Reply

What a horrible DIL! What if you couldn't be reached because you weren't told in advance daycare may call? I also can't believe the number of people siding with the DIL! Look, Grandma raised her kids, finding childcare should have been something DIL and hubby thought about before having kids, it is not the responsibility of other family members to raise their kids. Too many people today have kids and want everyone else to raise them.

-
-
Reply

Related Reads